Essential Listening #18: Comfortably Numb
My Comments
David Gilmour’s solos on this song are so emotional. He has such a great sound. I was in a cover band in the 80s and 90s called Sound Advice, later changed to 5 Below 0. This was always our last number. The crowd loved it. Great Memories. I could have easily put a dozen Pink Floyd songs in this list but I had to restrain myself.
Details
“Comfortably Numb” is a song by the British rock band Pink Floyd, released on their 1979 double album “The Wall.” It is one of the band’s most famous and critically acclaimed songs. Here are the key details about the song:
Song Composition and Theme
- Writers: David Gilmour (music) and Roger Waters (lyrics).
- Genre: Progressive rock, psychedelic rock.
- Theme: The song explores themes of alienation, numbness, and detachment. It tells the story of Pink, the protagonist of “The Wall” concept album, who is slipping into a state of drug-induced numbness and dissociation.
Musical Elements
- Structure: The song has a unique structure that includes two guitar solos by David Gilmour. It features verses sung by Roger Waters and choruses by David Gilmour.
- Key Signature: B minor.
- Guitar Solos: The song is renowned for its two guitar solos, particularly the second one, which is often cited as one of the greatest guitar solos in rock history.
- Arrangement: The song is characterized by its rich orchestration, including a prominent use of strings arranged by Michael Kamen.
Reception and Impact
- Critical Acclaim: “Comfortably Numb” is widely regarded as one of Pink Floyd’s greatest songs and one of the greatest rock songs of all time. It is a staple of classic rock radio.
- Legacy: The song is often included in lists of the greatest rock songs and is considered a highlight of Pink Floyd’s discography. It has been covered by numerous artists and is a staple in Pink Floyd’s and Roger Waters’ live performances.
Album Details
- Album: “The Wall”
- Release Date: November 30, 1979
- Label: Harvest Records, Columbia Records
- Producers: Bob Ezrin, David Gilmour, James Guthrie, and Roger Waters
Interpretation and Analysis
The song’s lyrics describe the protagonist, Pink, feeling a profound sense of detachment and numbness. This is conveyed through imagery of medical treatment and drug use, as Pink is sedated and loses touch with reality. The dialogue between the verses (sung by Waters) and the choruses (sung by Gilmour) represents the internal conflict within Pink’s mind.
Notable Lyrics
- Opening Lines: “Hello? Is there anybody in there? / Just nod if you can hear me / Is there anyone at home?”
- Chorus: “There is no pain,